REAL Workshops

These seminars focus on different themes of the REAL – ‘Rights and Egalitarianism' project and bring together researchers with expertise in a given theme. The format varies.

Details of upcoming REAL Workshops will be shared here when they are available.

Past Events

Tittle | ‘Equality of Opportunity, Justice, and Rights’

Date | 19 & 20 June, 2023

Location | TRiSS Seminar room, 6th floor, Arts Building, TCD

Time | See provisional schedule below

Confirmed Speakers: Kasper Lippert-Rasmussen (University of Aarhus), Emily McTernan (UCL) and David O’Brien (Tulane)

What is the relation between rights and egalitarian justice? There is a perception that the two pull in different directions, perhaps because rights are often conceptualised as individual entitlements and/or as deontological constraints while egalitarian theories of justice are taken to propose teleological principles whose satisfaction might infringe individual rights. Is this perception warranted? Are rights and egalitarianism in tension with each other or might they be compatible? Can principles of egalitarian justice be translated into (individual) rights and if so, should they?

One area where rights and egalitarianism appear to converge is equality of opportunity. Formal equality of opportunity, at least, can easily be translated into individual rights against discrimination. But equality of opportunity might require more than the rights against discrimination currently recognised in many jurisdictions; it might also require rights against socio-economic or class-based discrimination, which might be difficult to conceptualise and/or implement.

The 2nd REAL workshop seeks to address these and any other questions about the relation between rights and egalitarianism.

Monday, 19 June 2023

11am-11.15am: Welcome and introductions

11.15am-12.45pm: Showkat Ali - ‘An institutional account of fair equality of opportunity'

12.45pm-2pm: Lunch

2pm-3.30pm: Timo Juetten - ‘The harms of unfair competition'

3.30pm-3.45pm: Coffee

3.45pm-5.15pm: Emily McTernan - ‘Equality and the right to dissociate

7pm: Conference Dinner

 

Tuesday, 20 June 2023

9.30am-11am: Kasper Lippert-Rasmussen (with Bastian Steuwer) - ‘Poverty discrimination

11am-11.15am: Coffee

11.15am-12.45pm: Shalom Chalson - ‘Discounting people for reasons that shouldn’t count

12.45pm-2pm: Lunch

2pm-3.30pm: Matthew Palynchuk - ‘Distributive justice and the distributive view of disability

3.30pm-3.45pm: Coffee

3.45pm-5.15pm: Adi Goldiner - ‘From Disability Accommodations to Structural Modifications: The Case of Extended Time on Exams

 


 

Title | ‘Human rights and equality’ (on Zoom)

Date | 7 & 8 June, 2021

The kinds of justification or ground most commonly offered for human rights can be divided into instrumental and non-instrumental justifications.

According to the former, human rights protect valued features of human life; according to the latter, human rights are expressions of our inviolable moral status as persons. Both types of justification have significant limitations; the second one in particular, is arguably plagued by a vicious circularity problem, as several authors have noted: if inviolability is part of the definition of moral status, this seems to express the same idea as rights.

In light of these issues, this workshop explored alternative grounds and evaluations for human rights. In particular, the workshop considered (basic) equality as a possible ground for human rights and whether it can be understood in a way that is not reducible to either of the grounds mentioned earlier.

More generally, the workshop  considered the ways in which human rights and egalitarian commitments may converge or diverge.

Monday, June 7 2021

10am-11.30am: Adina Preda (TCD) - ‘Justifications of human rights

11.30am-12.30pm: Ian Carter (University of Pavia) - ‘Equality and opacity

12.30pm-1.30pm: Lunch break

1.30pm-2.30pm: Gopal Sreenivasan (Duke University) -  ‘Human rights and democratic legitimacy

2.45pm-4.15pm: Ariel Zylberman (University of Albany, SUNNY) - ‘Rights constitutivism

Tuesday, June 8 2021

10am-11.30am: Jiewuh Song (Seoul National University) - ‘Egalitarian reasons and human rights obligations'

11.30am-12.30pm: Kasper Lippert-Rasmussen (Aarhus University) - ‘Discrimination and moral equality of persons: Could we oppose the former and not accept the latter?

12.30pm-1.30pm: Lunch break

1.30pm-2.30pm: Laura Valentini (LMU Munich) -‘On the explanatory dispensability of natural rights

2.45pm-4.00pm: Jesse Tomalty (University of Bergen) - ‘Discrimination at the border