May Pick | Selected by Dr Rossella De Bernardi
Shani Orgad and Rosalind Gill | Confidence Culture
Who wouldn’t want to be, or at least look, more confident? Most will easily concede the undisputable value of confidence. In fact, to anyone raised as a woman, the question will easily sound quintessentially rhetorical. For within Western cultures – still a far cry from fulfilling their post-patriarchal aspirations – women’s grasp of self-confidence is as easily hard-won as it is short-lived, more a constant struggle than a peaceful, stable relationship. Luckily, from TikTok influencers to bestselling authors, resources abound to help us slay the beast of lack of confidence and finally be our best, most successful selves. We’ve just got to try harder!
In Confidence Culture, Professor of Media and Communications Shani Orgad and Professor of Cultural and Social Analysis Rosalind Gill put into words an ambivalence that I’ve long felt towards what they call the “confidence imperative.”
As they investigate the mixed messages of “body positivity” or confidence ideals in the workplace, Orgad and Gill's ultimate concern lies with unmasking how the cultural obsession with confidence works as a powerful depoliticising phenomenon; one that mistakes enduring structural obstacles to gender equality for psychological skill deficiencies and hinders our ability to question whether confidence truly deserves the prominence that is so often given. A highly recommended read!
May 2026
Dr Rossella De Bernardi
Post-Doctoral Fellow, Philosophy, Trinity College Dublin
Rossella’s fellowship project, Emotions and Injustice: An Egalitarian Theory of Affective Rights and Wrongs (2025–2027), explores the relationship between social processes and individual emotional life, with a focus on egalitarian theories of social justice and Public Reason Liberalism. Before joining Trinity, she held research positions at the University of Genoa and the University of Warwick, and taught at King’s College London and the University of Leeds. Her work has appeared in leading journals including the Journal of Social Philosophy and the Journal of Ethics and Social Philosophy. She holds a PhD (Political Philosophy) from the University of York, an MA (Philosophy) from the University of Pavia, and a BA (Philosophy) from the University of Genoa.